An encyclopedia article about a term proposed by Harvard Business School professor Andrew McAfee attracted a deletion discussion. McAfee and Karim R. Lakhani used the episode to study Wikipedia. Their case turns a broad question about quality into a specific one. How does a community decide that a subject belongs in a shared encyclopedia when people disagree about the evidence?
Separate the threshold from the drafting
A new contribution creates a page other contributors can improve. The threshold for keeping it addresses a different question. Editors can ask whether reliable sources independent of the subject have covered it sufficiently, or whether it belongs within a broader article. This makes the discussion about the available record instead of only the enthusiasm of the contributor.
A discussion page can preserve both the claim and the objections. The evidence needed to keep an article differs from the evidence needed to verify one sentence inside it. A source that establishes that someone first used a term can be relevant to a sentence even when it does little to establish the term’s independent significance.
Apply the same distinction to a smaller project
Consider a community-maintained directory. A contributor suggests adding an organization. The maintainers first agree how to decide whether the organization fits the directory. Only afterward do they verify its description, website and service area. Keeping the two decisions visible makes it easier to explain an omission. It also gives the next contributor a chance to find the exact evidence that was missing.
The Harvard case is historical. Its example makes the governance problem concrete. For current editorial procedures, read Wikipedia’s own documentation, where the entry bar and the process for resolving disagreements are open to inspection and revision.
Sources include Harvard Business School’s account of the case, Wikipedia’s notability guideline and Lakhani’s archived note about the case.
